Dancing With the Stars Eliminates 3rd Celebrity After "Shaky" Routine

And the elimination marked the third star to lose their spot in line for the Mirrorball following the ABC hit's two-night premiere, beginning Sept. 15. Secret Lives of Mormon Wives' Conner Leavitt was the first celebrity sent home after a salsa with pro Adele Zaikman didn't bring enough heat to the judges' table opening night.

"Obviously, going home first was not how I wanted to end my Dancing With the Stars experience," Conner, husband of DWTS semi-finalist Whitney Leavitt, explained on TikTok Sept. 17.  "But I can genuinely say I had an incredible time. I loved being out there. I loved learning something completely new."

Following his departure, Conner's fellow Hulu realityverse member Sarah Jane Nader was eliminated on night two. The Love Thy Nader personality was partnered with pro Hailey Bills, together becoming the show's third same-sex pairing. (JoJo Siwa and Jenna Johnson, who placed second on season 30, were the first.)

As such, the 24-year-old was proud of how her DWTS run honored her community as a bisexual woman, despite ending sooner than older sister Brooks Nader's ascent to ninth place with her now-ex Gleb Savchenko in 2024.

"As sad as we are to not dance next week—we were so excited—we're just grateful we had this opportunity," Sarah Jane told Good Morning America after the results. "Our partnership was so special. Not only because we became best friends, but because we represent a whole community."