GTA 6 Makes It Nearly Impossible to Play Without Killing Anyone

Nov 22, 2026 - 17:02
0 1
GTA 6 Makes It Nearly Impossible to Play Without Killing Anyone

Published Nov 22, 2026, 8:00 AM EST

In my defense, I don’t know how to drive IRL or in GTA

Jason Duval, one of two protagonists in GTA 6, robs an apparent gas station while a red bandana and yellow sunglasses cover his face. He points a gun toward the camera. Image: Rockstar Games

Sign in to your Polygon.com account

Grand Theft Auto 6 is out now, and for my initial playthrough of Rockstar’s latest giant open-world game, I wanted to try something a bit out of left field: How long could I play without killing anyone? I’d do my best Batman impression: brutally beating my foes, crippling them with excessive medical debt, but keeping them alive.

Yeah, that didn’t last long. Turns out trying to not commit crime in the game that’s all about committing crime is a difficult task.

The first mission was easy enough. Jason has to rescue drug runner Donnie from a gang of rednecks who keep tigers in cages. (Surely that will end well for them.) After I rescued him, I got into a fist fight with a beefy boy and knocked him out. So far so good. Jason had a pistol on him and could pick up weapons around the swamp base, but, trying to avoid a shootout at all costs, I stealthily booked it away from the rednecks and toward the water, avoiding any detection (and potential for violence).

That was the opening mostly-on-the-rails mission, but things quickly went south when I was left to my own devices. During the next in-game day, players are given a few mission options. I met up with Cal, Jason’s buddy who’s not cut out for a life of crime, and we drove to a police impound lot. I needed to steal a car with a trunk full of weed, and this is where shit hit the fan.

Look, I never learned how to drive in real life, and am not the biggest fan of it in video games. Driving for more than a few feet without hitting anything or anyone is an impossible challenge in games, and driving in GTA 6 feels especially difficult; I can never figure out the right speed to go, and sharp turns are the bane of my existence.

So maybe I was always doomed to run over a cop on my way out of the impound lot.

Jason rides a motorcycle in Grand Theft Auto 6. Image: Rockstar Games via Polygon

Police officers swarmed Jason after he unhooked the red Phoenix and hotwired it. Too much was happening at once: an on-screen message about how I could open the gate, cops flinging open the driver’s side door and trying to rip Jason from the vehicle, and police radio chatter pouring out of my controller speaker. I’m not ashamed to say I restarted this mission several times just trying to figure out how to get out of the lot by carefully not running over any cops.

And then, who pulls up in front of the gate I’m about to crash through but a do-gooder cop hopping out of his vehicle? I assumed the giant pool of blood leaking out of him after our collision meant he wasn’t long for the world.

I did get caught on that attempt (again, driving is hard), and had to restart. On my next attempt, I got away blood free. Did that mean I succeeded in not killing anyone, or did the roadkill cop mean I failed? Didn’t matter, since soon after I killed someone and there was no going back.

After purchasing a longarm from an Ammu-Nation, Jason gets jumped. This was my first fistfight, meaning I had to navigate on-screen messages telling me how to fight while trying not to die. I was just pressing buttons, y’all. Instinctively I pressed whatever button flashed up on screen, which meant, after knocking out one dude, I picked up his knife and started attacking with it. Knives — much more lethal than Jason’s fists!

I killed one goon before dropping the knife and knocking out the third and final guy. I checked my playthrough stats and, yep, that guy was definitely dead. And I was barely two hours into the game. There’s a lot to do in GTA 6, and plenty of control schemes to learn just to be able to do all that stuff. Players have already accidentally kicked bodega cats (heinous) because of a fumbled button press.

Lucia holds a gun in Grand Theft Auto 6. Image: Rockstar Games

Still, not to be deterred by my early-game kills, I tried to soldier on with committing as little murder as possible. I soon learned this was impossible. During the “Hey, Arnold” mission, Jason gets into a car chase with one of landlord Brian’s old buddies. Arnold’s got goons on motorcycles protecting him and, ya know, I said I wasn’t very good at driving.

I tried my damndest not to kill them, but that wasn’t going to happen. I accidentally ran into some, and they didn’t survive their facetime with Brian’s big-ass truck. But, hey, at least I got to spare Arnold at the end.

I’ve played a few hours since, and have tried to keep up my “no killing” policy. It’s especially tough in shootouts as Rockstar’s third-person shooting has never been the most fluid, and aiming for nonvital parts of people — when getting shot at myself — is a tall task. Still I’ve kept it up. I’ve enjoyed how you can incapacitate enemies by shooting them in the legs; the hit indicator will turn yellow to show that they’ve been wounded, but not killed. Now, is that guy I shot — but didn’t kill! — who then lay unmoving and face-first in knee-high water really going to get back up again? Who knows, but I did my best to not kill him.

Jason and Lucia hold guns in Grand Theft Auto 6. Image: Rockstar Games

GTA 6 is hyperrealistic, to the point that sometimes people can’t tell the difference between GTA 6 footage and real life. That realism extends to each of its hand-crafted NPCs. They look and behave so much like real people that I’m hesitant to just pull out a gun and start blasting, a sentiment that prospective players shared ahead of the game’s release.

Violence toward very-real-looking humans is something I’ve thought a lot about this year, and the restrictions on it in 007 First Light is part of what made that game really appeal to me. Pragmata and Onimusha: Way of the Sword are two of my favorite games this year, and I have to think that’s partly due to the fact that the violence in them is directed toward robots and demons, respectively. I don’t really have to think twice about slicing a people-devouring demon in half. Firing on small-time crooks in Vice City? That’s something that will give me pause.

I don’t know how much longer I’ll try to keep up my self-imposed difficulty modifier and continue on with as little violence as possible. After all, the appeal of this series is, ya know, committing crime. Hey, sometimes you gotta shoot some dudes in GTA 6 before they shoot you. But it was certainly fun while it lasted.

Polygon's GTA 6 hub

Everything GTA 6

Updates from Leonida

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0

Comments (0)

User