From Dumb Starbucks to dada documentary: everything you need to know about Nathan Fielder

Nov 18, 2026 - 17:15
0 3
From Dumb Starbucks to dada documentary: everything you need to know about Nathan Fielder

“There are three sides to every story: your side, my side, and the truth. And no one is lying. Memories shared serve each differently.” Those words were spoken by film producer Robert Evans – but nobody has ever interrogated the idea more skilfully than comedian Nathan Fielder.

The three-hour documentary You Can See Everything – co-directed by and starring Fielder – opens in the UK on Friday, having already become an unlikely cultural phenomenon and box office sensation in the US. The film follows disgraced Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes in the weeks leading up to her beginning a prison sentence for defrauding investors; what emerges is a profound meditation on the nature of truth and the fundamental unknowability of other human beings. To view the film as being simply about the Theranos scandal is akin to considering Casablanca merely a movie about a nightclub. And, as one might expect given Fielder’s background, it’s hilarious.

Fielder, a high school friend of Seth Rogen, first came to international prominence with Nathan for You, a parody reality series that showcased his unique brand of weaponised awkwardness. He played “himself”, just as he does in You Can See Everything; the idea initially was that this was a man attempting to aid struggling businesses since he had, we were unreliably informed during the opening credits, “graduated from one of Canada’s top business schools with really good grades”.

From the off, it was clear this was a comedian more interested in situationist chaos than mere pranks. There was something of the Andy Kaufman about his approach, a dadaist philosophy as opposed to a Jeremy Beadle one. The series evolved and expanded but, over the course of 32 episodes, it was by some distance the funniest thing on television. To help a small electronics store losing money, Fielder concocted a plan involving $1 television sets that could only be bought after completing an extreme obstacle course involving a live alligator. In another episode, a struggling coffee shop was rebranded as “Dumb Starbucks”, thereby exploiting a parody law loophole and becoming a viral sensation in the process.

The show went far beyond its original premise and ended up occupying a position on the Venn diagram where comedy overlaps with performance art. One third season episode, Smokers Allowed, seemed to mark a turning point in Fielder’s career. Over an extraordinary 21 minutes, he was tasked with reviving the fortunes of a bar. After discovering punters would be allowed to smoke in the establishment so long as events were presented as a “play” (for an audience of two), he filmed a standard night at the bar and hired actors to recreate the “events” verbatim – a ploy that seems to have more in common with Charlie Kaufman’s autofiction than Trigger Happy TV.

Smokers Allowed and the feature length Nathan for You episode, Finding Frances, now look like rehearsals for, well, The Rehearsal, the show that came next. This series put the “Fielder method” front and centre: a technique developed in Nathan for You involving Fielder and his collaborators role-playing absurd scenarios in an attempt to second guess how a member of the public might react when the cameras were rolling. They inevitably struggled to predict what would happen, but were amused by the human need to try to control the future, a losing battle since time immemorial. For those of us who rehearse orders in our head before speaking to a waiter, or refuse to go to a concert without having revised the setlist in advance, this was a genuine representation of the psyche.

Nathan Fielder stands outside a cockpit looking in at the pilot
High flying … Fielder in the aviation-themed second series of The Rehearsal. Photograph: HBO/2025 Home Box Office, Inc

The first series of The Rehearsal saw Fielder attempting to aid a woman contemplating motherhood; while the second saw him effect real change in regard to global aviation safety, with an attempt to cut down on the number of airline crashes. Not bad for a man who, just over a decade earlier, opened the first episode of Nathan for You with a segment involving poo flavoured frozen yoghurt.

Analysis of Fielder’s work often focuses on attempts to verify certain truths and determine the degree of poetic licence involved. And yet, to play this game is to entirely miss the point. Such speculation is infantile and one can only imagine the very same people bemoaning Picasso’s portraits for not looking lifelike or criticising Paradise Lost for Milton’s resolute failure to make it rhyme.

Fielder and his co-director, Lance Oppenheim, conceived You Can See Everything while watching card tricks at the Magic Castle in Los Angeles. Fielder was passionate about stage magic in his teens and even worked in a magic shop in a shopping mall, a rare biographical detail that helps illuminate the work. In almost every Fielder project, you can feel that love of illusions and the power of misdirection, something equally valuable when attempting to make people laugh. There are, of course, those who wish to know the mechanics of how an illusion works – but the better option is to simply sit back and enjoy the greatest trick Fielder has ever pulled.

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0

Comments (0)

User