Magic: The Gathering Designers Reveal the Best Commander in Their Dune Crossover
The designers behind Magic’s Dune crossover explain their biggest challenges — and address a fan-favorite character’s absence
Image: Wizards of the CoastMagic: The Gathering is heading to Arrakis, and its designers decided Paul Atreides, Chani, and the Bene Gesserit deserved more than familiar reprints featuring new artwork. The upcoming Secret Lair collaboration, teased Tuesday and formally announced Wednesday, Nov. 18, features nine mechanically unique cards across three collections, alongside reprints that bring Dune’s spice harvesters, the iconic crysknife, and the infamous pain box to the tabletop.
“My Arrakis, My Superdrop” goes on sale Nov. 30 through the Secret Lair website, and it draws directly from Denis Villeneuve’s cinematic adaptation of Frank Herbert’s universe. (So yes, you’re about to see the likes of Timothée Chalamet, Zendaya, Florence Pugh, and Rebecca Ferguson on Magic cards.) The Balance of Power Drop introduces eight legendary creatures, while Deserts of Arrakis adds the massive sandworms the Fremen refer to as Shai-Hulud. The halo foil collection Spice rounds out the crossover with five reprints.
To learn how the team translated Dune’s iconic characters and really big worms into Magic mechanics — and why Duncan Idaho didn’t make the roster — Polygon sent questions to senior game designers Arya Karamchandani and Benjamin Weitz and product architect Steve Sunu. Check out their answers below.
Image: Wizards of the CoastPolygon: Did you consider representing Dune’s characters through reprints, or were mechanically unique cards always the goal?
Steve Sunu: From a product design perspective, Secret Lair always strives to do what's most authentic to the partner and to Magic. When it came to Dune, it was a really special and unique opportunity, especially given its impact on storytelling and art, both of which are important to Magic players. We consider every angle for partners, and that includes whether to reprint existing designs, or develop entirely new cards to help represent characters and concepts. For Dune, we determined that this could be our one chance to bring these characters to Magic. At that point, unique designs weren't just a possibility, it was a must-have.
That said, there were some concepts that did map well to existing Magic cards, and we were able to integrate those into the other Drops in ways that we hope are fun and thematic for players and fans. Something like a Quicksilver Amulet re-contextualized as a Thumper is always fun for us to try out, so we were pleased to include some of those resonant cards in the Drops.
What was the character, item, or event from the Dune world that you were most excited to adapt into a Magic card? And what was the most challenging one to adapt?
Arya Karamchandani: I really enjoyed adapting the various powers of the Bene Gesserit to Magic's rules system. Dune is a little less fantastical than a lot of Magic settings, but the Bene Gesserit's powers are among the more magical elements within the world of Dune and feel right at home within Magic. Representing Paul's precognition with a "Future Sight" effect and The Voice as Goading really helped tie the world of Dune to iconic Magic effects that players are familiar to players with while remaining accurate to the source material.
Image: Wizards of the CoastOn a similar note, representing characters like Emperor Shaddam and The Baron, who exercise more subtle political power, was a more challenging task. We ended up leaning on powerful non-combat abilities to represent these characters instead, so while they may not dominate a battlefield the way Chani does, they still loom over the game in a way that feels very resonant.
Benjamin Weitz: Shai-Hulud was definitely the most exciting one for me. One of the iconic aspects of Dune is its scale: City-sized worms annihilate the Harkonnen forces in a Galactic-level conflict. To convey this feeling, we made Shai-Hulud absolutely enormous and destructive, so that it would be one of the most dominant creatures on the game board. But we also made sure to include a more subtle nod to the Dune lore: The sandworms are terraformers that bring life to the desert of Arrakis, and so we made sure Shai-Hulud was not only destructive but also life-giving.
The schemers and political characters were both exciting challenges for the team. Finding different ways of representing collusion or subtlety was tricky, since the majority of the Dune characters are known for both. The Bene Gesserit, in particular, are known for keeping to the shadows and forming alliances. Mohiam and Irulan will help your opponents, but if you use their abilities cleverly, you’ll be able to maneuver yourself into claiming the lion’s share of the benefits.
Image: Wizards of the CoastThe Balance of Power set features some legendary creatures that seem like promising Commanders. Is there any card from that group that you are particularly excited to see players build new decks around?
Karamchandani: Both Muad’Dib and Chani are personal favorites of mine. We wanted to make sure both of them were independently cool cards, and powerful Commanders in their own right. If you do end up playing them in the same deck, though, Chani’s ability to play extra lands pairs really well with Muad'Dib's Delirium text, smoothing out some of the issues cards in this vein often have. I’m excited to watch players find the cards that play well in the overlap between their strategies.
Weitz: Mohiam is my personal favorite design in the Drop. I love a symmetric effect that takes some work to break the symmetry. Mohiam requires some care and planning to set up the top card of your library, but she lets you cheat some powerful spells if you’re willing to pay the costs. Or you could use her to form an alliance with another player, giving you both access to more mana and spells to take down whoever is the current leader at the table. I generally shy away from too much politics when I play Commander, but with Mohiam it just feels right.
One fan-favorite Dune character who didn't get a card is Duncan Idaho. Did you consider making one? What is Duncan's color identity?
Karamchandani: We definitely considered it; ultimately, there were only so many cards we could make. Duncan’s loyalty to House Atreides and his abilities as an unrivaled fighter definitely place him squarely within red and white for me. By the time we see him on screen, he has also forged a strong connection with the Fremen and Arrakis, a faction I consider quite green, putting him in white, red, and green for me.
Photo: Chiabella James/Warner Bros. PicturesWeitz: I’d say Duncan is primary white-green, with some tertiary red. He’s very driven by loyalty and honor, and after befriending the Fremen, he has a deep respect for their culture and the environment of Arrakis. He can be a little hot-headed and emotional, which gives him some red aspects, but he is a pretty straightforward general and member of House Atreides.
Sunu: There were so many characters on the table for these Secret Lair Drops. At the end of the day, we could cover only so much ground. We had a lot of ideas for how Duncan Idaho might appear, but we decided not to include him in any of the cards that we've shown. Never say never on seeing your favorite character in Magic, though.
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)